Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Red Sox manager Terry Francona could have been selected by the Yankees in the 1980 amateur draft.

Yesterday, we took a look at the Yankees’ complete list of first round selections. Aside from the significant number of players who never even made the majors, what jumps out most is that from 1979 to 1989, the Yankees only had two first round selections in the June draft.

Listed below is a chart that displays the player drafted in the Yankees’ forfeited slot along with the corresponding free agent that necessitated the transfer. As you can see, the Yankees actually made out much better in the swap as the teams selecting in their spot made some awful choices. Of course, the Yankees still could have selected an alternative (the best of which are also displayed in the chart), but judging by their track record, not to mention the chaotic front office structure of the 1980s, that’s probably wishful thinking.

Year PK Lost to: Player Selected WAR Comp For: WAR1 Could Have Had:2
1979 25 Dodgers Steve Perry N/A Tommy John 15.1 Chris Brown
1980 22 Expos T. Francona -3.7 Rudy May 6.6 Dan Pleasac
1981 26 Padres Frank Castro NA Dave Winfield 25.6 Mark Langston
1982 22 Reds Scott Jones NA Dave Collins -0.6 David Wells
1983 13 White Sox Joel Davis 0.5 Steve Kemp 1.2 Roger Clemens
1985* 23 Padres Joey Cora 4.5 Ed Whitson -2.5 Randy Johnson
1986 25 Angels Terry Carr NA Al Holland -1.0 Kevin Tapani
1987 23 Rangers Bill Hasselman 2.2 Gary Ward -0.9 Travis Fryman
1988 22 Cardinals John Ericks 0.4 Jack Clark 3.1 Alex Fernandez
1989 15 Dodgers Kiki Jones NA Steve Sax 7.5 Mo Vaughn

1 WAR calculated only for consecutive tenure following related free agent signing.
2 Based on notable players selected shortly after the indicated draft slot.

*Until 1986, baseball also held an amateur draft in January for those college and high school players graduating over the winter. Although the available players were not nearly as talented, an occasional diamond in the rough was found every now and then. One example was Tim Belcher, whom the Yankees uncovered with the first overall selection in secondary phase of the 1984 January draft. Unfortunately for the Yankees, 1984 was also a year in which baseball had a free agent compensation system that allowed teams losing a Type-A player to select an unprotected member of any major league roster. Adding to the team’s misfortune was that the fact that protection lists were due in on January 13, almost a month before the Yankees even signed Belcher. Still, due to a loophole in the system, the Oakland Athletics were able to snatch Belcher from the Yankees when they lost free agent Tom Underwood to the Orioles.

The Yankees eventually filed a protest on the sound logic that they had no means to protect Belcher, a scenario that could not have been the intended by the governing collective bargaining agreement. The Yankees’ argument was clearly valid, but as often was the case at the time, George Steinbrenner was embroiled in a running feud with American League president Lee MacPhail, this time stemming from the events of the previous season’s Pine Tar Game. So, MacPhail gladly seized upon the opportunity to stick it to Steinbrenner by denying the protest and giving the Yankees a supplemental pick in the 1985 June draft instead. The Yankees wound up selecting Anthony Balabon, a pitcher who never made it the majors. Meanwhile, Tim Belcher went on to have a very solid 14 year career.

The Yankees threw most draft watchers a curve by selecting unheralded Cito Culver, a short stop out of Irondequoit High School in Rochester, New York. With several highly touted names like Anthony Ranaudo, Peter Tago, Tyrell Jenkins and Nick Castellanos still on the board, the choice of Culver, who was ranked outside of most pre-draft top-100 projections, is curious to say the least.

The Yankees have been following Culver since last summer, so perhaps they’ve seen something that everyone else has overlooked. As a 17-year old, switch hitting short stop, Culver clearly offers a considerable payoff, so this may simply be a case of high risk/high reward. Then again, it could also suggest that the Yankees were simply not willing to go over slot for some of the more established names that were still available. Although Culver, who has a commitment to attend the University of Maryland, will not be cheap, it stands to reason that he will not command as much of a bonus as those ranked far ahead of him.

Regardless of their motivation, the Yankees have now clearly shifted away from their strategy of drafting college age pitchers and are now focusing on replenishing their system with athletic, tools oriented position players. Last year, the Yankees also went for up-the-middle talent by selecting high school centerfielder Slade Heathcott. Of course, the team’s aging position players likely means a contingency plan will be necessary before guys like Culver and Heathcott will be ready to contribute.

Before getting too carried away with draft analysis, it is important to remember that amateur projections in baseball are far from an exact science. For all we know, the Yankees’ future short stop may not be Culver, but someone selected much later in the draft (or even more likely, someone currently playing for another team). For some perspective, listed below is a break down of the Yankees’ past first round selections.

Yankees First Rounder Selections By Year

Year Pick Player
2010 32 Cito Culver (unsigned)
2009 29 Zachary Heathcott (minors)
2008 28 Gerrit Cole (unsigned)
2008 44 Jeremy Bleich (minors)
2007 30 Andrew Brackman (minors)
2006 21 Ian Kennedy
2006 41 Joba Chamberlain
2005 17 Carl Henry (minors)
2004 23 Phil Hughes
2004 37 Jonathan Poterson (minors)
2004 41 Jeffrey Marquez (minors)
2003 27 Eric Duncan (minors)
2001 23 John-Ford Griffin
2001 34 Bronson Sardinha
2001 42 Jon Skaggs (minors)
2000 28 David Parrish (minors)
1999 27 David Walling (minors)
1998 24 Andy Brown (minors)
1998 43 Mark Prior
1997 24 Tyrell Godwin
1997 40 Ryan Bradley
1996 20 Eric Milton
1995 27 Shea Morenz (minors)
1994 24 Brian Buchanan
1993 13 Matt Drews (minors)
1992 6 Derek Jeter
1991 1 Brien Taylor (minors)
1990 10 Carl Everett
1985 28 Anthony Balabon (minors)
1984 22 Jeff Pries (minors)
1978 18 Rex Hudler
1978 24 Matt Winters
1978 26 Brian Ryder (minors)
1977 23 Steve Taylor
1976 16 Pat Tabler
1975 19 Jim McDonald
1974 12 Dennis Sherrill
1973 13 Doug Heinhold
1972 14 Scott McGregor
1971 19 Terry Whitfield
1970 12 Dave Cheadle
1969 11 Charlie Spikes
1968 4 Thurman Munson
1967 1 Ron Blomberg
1966 10 Jim Lyttle
1965 19 Bill Burbach

Yankees First Rounder Selections By Position/School

Position Count Most Notable
C 3 Thurman Munson
1B 3 Ron Blomberg
2B 0  
SS 6 Derek Jeter
3B 2 Charlie Spikes
OF 10 Carl Everett
RHP 17 Mark Prior
LHP 5 Scott McGregor
Drafted From    
4-Year College 17  
Jr. College 1  
High School 28  

Yankees First Rounder Selections Ranked By WAR

Drafted Player Pos WAR
1992 Derek Jeter SS 68.8
1968 Thurman Munson C 43.4
1990 Carl Everett OF 18.4
1972 Scott McGregor LHP 17.5
1996 Eric Milton LHP 13.9
1998 Mark Prior RHP 13.7
1967 Ron Blomberg 1B 8.7
1978 Rex Hudler SS 5.3
1971 Terry Whitfield OF 4.6
2006 Joba Chamberlain RHP 4.3
1976 Pat Tabler OF 2.7
2004 Phil Hughes RHP 2.2
2001 John-Ford Griffin OF 0.3
1966 Jim Lyttle OF 0.1
1974 Dennis Sherrill SS 0
1997 Tyrell Godwin OF -0.1
1997 Ryan Bradley RHP -0.1
1994 Brian Buchanan 1B -0.2
1969 Charlie Spikes 3B -0.2
2001 Bronson Sardinha SS -0.3
1970 Dave Cheadle LHP -0.3
2006 Ian Kennedy RHP -0.4
1978 Matt Winters OF -0.6
1965 Bill Burbach RHP -1.7

Note: Only players with major league experience listed.

17-year old Bryce Harper is the face of the 2010 amateur draft.

On the eve of unveiling last year’s prize from the 2009 amateur draft, the Nationals are once again projected to get a very special player with the first pick in this year’s draft, which begins tonight at 7:00PM ET. Although not as highly touted as Stephen Strasburg, Bryce Harper is this year’s wunderkind. Harper, a 17-year old catcher who accelerated his high school graduation so he could enroll at a junior college and hasten his entry into the draft, is universally regarded as not only the best player available, but one of the more advanced hitters at his age in recent memory.

Tempering the Nationals’ good fortune of getting to select two of the most promising number one picks in the history of the draft is the fact that they will once again have to negotiate with Scott Boras, meaning the team can expect to pay somewhere close to fair value. Even more daunting for the Nationals this time around is the leverage possessed by Harper thanks to his young age. Unlike a college player with no leverage, or even a high school player who is already 18, Harper could opt not to sign, play a second year in junior college and still be as young as a high school senior entering  the 2011 draft. Sounds like a master plan that only someone like Scott Boras could devise.

With all of that drama as a backdrop for tonight’s draft, which is slowly gaining traction as an attention getting event, the Yankees find themselves once again picking at the end of the first round (a small price to pay for winning the World Series). As always, the Yankees are rumored to be a likely landing spot for several players with signability issues, but at such a late slot in the first round, that’s really nothing more than conjecture. Listed below is a quick summary of the Yankees’ projected pick with the 32nd overall selection, based on the mock drafts of several noted amateur baseball analysts.

Analyst Draftee School
Keith Law, ESPN.com Tyrell Jenkins, RHP Henderson HS (Texas)
Jim Callis, Baseball America Christian Yelich, 1B Westlake HS (CA)
Jonathan Mayo, MLB.com Austin Wates, OF Virginia Tech
John Sickels, minorleagueball.com Tyrell Jenkins, RHP Henderson HS (Texas)
Kevin Goldstein, Baseball Prospectus Gary Brown, OF Cal State Fullerton
Frankie Piliere, mlb.fanhouse.com Jedd Gyorko, SS West Virginia

For a complete scouting report on each player, along with video, check out the MLB.com’s Draft Central.

The Yankees were two innings away from being swept to the precipice of fourth place when the offense finally started to hit…or, rather, get hit. Trailing 2-0 in the top of the 8th, starter Brandon Morrow started the inning by hitting Francisco Cervelli in the shoulder. Then, reliever Scott Downs followed up by plunking Brett Gardner on the forearm to give the Yankees their most formidable rally of the game.

Joe Girardi makes a few points to home plate umpire Bruce Dreckman, whose erratic strike zone drew the ire of both teams.

With the tying runs on base, Derek Jeter worked Downs to what seemed like a 2-1 count, but home plate umpire Bruce Dreckman, whose strike zone was erratic all game, called the third pitch a strike despite it being well off the outside corner. Ironically, the poor call turned the game in the Yankees favor because the next pitch was in a similar location, but instead of taking it, Jeter slashed it down the right field line for a double. The clutch hit scored Cervelli and sent Gardner to third, but things got a little anxious after Swisher was called out by Dreckman on a check swing that replays clearly revealed was held. The frustration of Dreckman’s mounting bad calls led Girardi out of the dugout for an argument that culminated in his ejection.

Meanwhile, Cito Gaston had a tough decision to make, and like many managers before him, opted to walk the struggling Mark Teixeira to face Alex Rodriguez with the bases loaded (Arod had been 5-5 with 18 RBIs in that scenario). Before the Frasor/Arod confrontation could be decided, however, a wild pitch that squirted about 15 feet from Jose Molina allowed Gardner to slide home with the tying run. Perhaps distracted by not having the bases loaded, Arod then took a called third strike down the middle, setting the Yankees up for another wasted opportunity.  Gaston first had another  decision to make, and inexplicably decided to let the right handed Jason Frasor face Robinson Cano, who promptly slashed a single to left that scored both Jeter and Teixeira.

The reason the punchless Yankees were able to hang around in the game was because Javier Vazquez was brilliant once again. After watching the Jays do most of their damage in the series off of the fastball, Vazquez attacked the Toronto hitters with an over abundance of off speed pitches. Nearly 60% of pitches thrown by Vazquez were of the off speed variety, including a combined 45% that were either a change or curve. Ironically, the pattern used by Vazquez was the same one that many believe caused his early season struggles, but against the aggressive, fast ball hunting Jays, it was a recipe for success.

For the first 5 2/3 innings, Vazquez racked up eight strikeouts with out giving up a hit. After walking Adam Lind, however, Vazquez hung a slider to Vernon Wells, who promptly hit deep into the left field seats to give the Jays a 2-0 lead. At the time, it seemed as if one mistake would Vazquez a hard luck loser because the Yankees didn’t seem to have a chance against Morrow, who used a fastball that averaged 96mph to dominate the Yankee batters.

After two games of facing change-up masters in Cecil and Romero, Morrow’s heat had to seem like lightning. After Gardner’s one out triple in the third, Morrow retired the next 13 batters, a string that was broken when Cano singled with two outs in the seventh. Despite handling the Yankees with such ease, however, the Yankees’ less than thunderous rally in the 8th set him up on the hard luck end of the game. Continue Reading »

The Stadium slugfest may have been held in the Bronx last night, but during the afternoon in Toronto, the Yankees and Blue Jays compiled more punch outs than Mike Tyson did in his entire career.

After perhaps their most abysmal offensive performance of the year, epitomized by Mark Teixeira’s record tying five strikeout performance, the Yankees will look to rebound against Jays’ struggling starter Brandon Morrow, who enters the game with an ERA of 6.00, although he did pitch very well in his last outing against the Rays. To his credit, Joe Girardi has not decided to panic and has posted nearly the same lineup that struck out and astounding 16 times in yesterday’s 14-inning game. Undoubtedly, all eyes will be on Mark Teixeira as he seeks to wash away the sour taste of yesterday’s horrendous performance.

In Javier Vazquez, the Yankees are also sending their own 6-ERA pitcher to the mound. Vazquez has pitched well in three of last four starts, however, so the Yankees need to hope he can continue that trend. On the one hand, the power laden Jays seem like bad matchup for Vazquez, who has already surrendered 10 homeruns and has always been prone to the long ball. Then again, Vazquez has a vast arsenal of pitches, including a plus changeup and curve, two pitches that most of the Jays’ batters have proven unable to hit. Ironically, if Vazquez reverts to the formula that caused his early season struggles (too much off speed and not throwing enough fastballs for strikes), he could wind up pitching a very good game.

Coming after two tough losses to the Rays, the Blue Jays needed to make a statement and they did. Another win would only make it that much more emphatic.

While the Jays came into the series limping a little, it is the Yankees who now find themselves badly in need of a victory. Aside from the Twins, whom they seem to beat just by showing up, the Yankees have had only one victory (against the Tigers on May 14) against an over-.500 team since April 21. Even though the June schedule provides a host of low quality teams, the Yankees will eventually need to start playing better against better teams if they hope to vie for playoff spot. In the meantime, they now find themselves closer to fourth place than first.

vs. Brandon Morrow PA BA OBP SLG HR RBI
Derek Jeter SS 10 0.125 0.300 0.250 0 2
Nick Swisher RF 4 0.333 0.500 0.333 0 0
Mark Teixeira 1B 7 0.200 0.429 0.200 0 1
Alex Rodriguez 3B 11 0.222 0.364 0.556 1 2
Robinson Cano 2B 9 0.286 0.444 0.286 0 0
Jorge Posada DH 5 0.667 0.800 0.667 0 0
Curtis Granderson CF 2 0.500 0.500 0.500 0 0
Francisco Cervelli C 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0
Brett Gardner LF 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0
Total 48 0.270 0.438 0.378 1 5
vs. Javier Vazquez PA BA OBP SLG HR RBI
Fred Lewis LF 3 0.333 0.333 0.333 0 0
Aaron Hill 2B 12 0.091 0.167 0.182 0 1
Adam Lind DH 3 0.333 0.333 0.333 0 0
Vernon Wells CF 35 0.171 0.171 0.371 1 1
Jose Bautista 3B 5 0.600 0.600 1.800 2 2
Alex Gonzalez SS 41 0.342 0.390 0.553 1 4
Lyle Overbay 1B 23 0.300 0.348 0.450 0 4
Jeremy Reed RF 5 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0
Jose Molina C 8 0.143 0.250 0.286 0 0
Total 135 0.252 0.289 0.457 4 12
Yankees vs. Blue Jays
Season: 2010 Season: 2009 Season: 2008 All-Time
TOR: 2-0 NYY: 12-6 TIED: 9-9 NYY: 259-203

A Yankee fan growing up, Brett Cecil wasn’t very kind to the team for which he used to root. The young Jays lefty kept the Yankees off balance for most of the game with a dynamic changeup, which he threw a relatively high 28 times, including 19 times for strikes (mostly swinging). With the exception of a few hard hit balls, the Yankees were mostly unable to adjust to Cecil’s off speed approach, which also included 30 sliders.

What's his secret? Jose Bautista shares a moment with Lyle Overbay after belting his second home run of the game (Photo: AP).

AJ Burnett would have been wise to take a page from Cecil because the Jays made him pay for several poorly located fastballs. Burnett did throw more curves than usual (40% versus 24% for the season), but his inability to get ahead in the count left him in too many predictable hitters counts. As a result, the fastball happy Jays made him pay, driving in all six runs off old number one.

Coming into the game, AJ Burnett had only allowed four HRs, but by the end of the day he had nearly doubled that total to seven. Most of the damage was done by Jose Bautista, who belted two round trippers on fastballs down the middle: one on a 3-2 count leading off the second and the other at 2-0 with a runner on in the fourth. Coming into the game, Bautista ranked eight in the American League in runs above average produced on the fastball (11.8), so the pitch selection was curious to say the least. Nonetheless, Bautista’s two homeruns boosted his league leading total to 18 and set a new career high in the process.

The Yankees did have two chances to make a dent in Cecil’s armor, but were thwarted by a double play each time. In the fourth inning, a Swisher walk and Mark Teixeira single put runners on first and second with no outs, but Arod followed with a hard smash up the middle the short stop Alex Gonzalez impressively turned into a double play. Then, in the sixth inning, Nick Swisher hit into a twin killing that scored Chad Moeller with the Yankees only run. Otherwise, the Yankees’ offense was punchless against the crafty Cecil.

Despite AJ Burnett’s frustrating pitch selection, the Yankees can’t kick themselves over this one. Cecil pitched a great game and even had some luck to boot. The Jays, however, really needed to make a strong showing. After blowing consecutive games to the Rays, another loss in the division could have introduced some doubts about the team’s staying power. Now, the onus is placed on the Yankees to even the series by playing a better game against better competition.

  • By going 0-4, Robin Cano’s 17-game hitting streak came to an end.
  • Cecil’s 1-run, 8-inning performance was his second of the season, the other occurring on May 3 versus the Indians.
  • With three homeruns, the Jays increased their league leading total to 94. The franchise record for most homeruns is 244, which was established in 2000.

The Yankees travel north to face the Blue Jays for the first time this season and will encounter a power laden team that leads the league in HRs by 17. Ironically, it isn’t proven stars like Aaron Hill and Adam Lind who are leading the power surge, but journeymen like Jose Bautista and Alex Gonzalez.

Usually, it is the Yankees who dominate in the power department, but Cito Gaston’s HR happy Jays have turned the tables on the Bronx Bombers. Having said that, the Jays rank next to last in .OBP, which helps explain why the Yankees, who lead the league in getting on base, have still scored 24 more runs despite hitting almost 30 fewer long balls.

AJ Burnett will be charged with containing the Jays power, which based on early season statistics seems like a good choice. In over 70 innings, Burnett has only allowed four HRs, so the Yankees hope that bodes well for his performance. Similarly, Brett Cecil, a strike throwing lefty, seems to match up well against the Yankees patient approach. Styles often make the fight, and this matchup could be an example of that.

The Jays come into the game off of two straight losses to the Rays, both the result of blown saves in the ninth inning. The unexpected fourth horse in the race, the Jays need to bounce back against the Yankees if they hope to avoid falling further back in the division. It remains to be seen if the Jays are for real, but beating the Yankees this weekend would be a good place to start.

The Yankees meanwhile come off seven straight games against pretty awful teams, so the Jays represent a step up in class. In order to keep pace is a very tight divisional race, the Yankees need to keep winning series, and the best way to do that is by winning game one.

vs. Brett Cecil PA BA OBP SLG HR RBI
Derek Jeter SS 6 0.600 0.667 0.600 0 0
Nick Swisher RF 6 0.333 0.333 0.333 0 1
Mark Teixeira 1B 6 0.333 0.667 1.333 1 1
Alex Rodriguez 3B 3 0.333 0.333 0.333 0 0
Robinson Cano 2B 6 0.800 0.833 1.400 1 1
Jorge Posada DH 6 0.600 0.667 0.600 0 2
Marcus Thames LF 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0
Curtis Granderson CF 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0
Chad Moeller C 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0
Total 33 0.519 0.606 0.741 2 5
vs. AJ Burnett PA BA OBP SLG HR RBI
Fred Lewis LF 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0
Aaron Hill 2B 12 0.273 0.333 0.545 1 1
Adam Lind DH 10 0.250 0.400 0.250 0 0
Vernon Wells CF 10 0.333 0.400 0.778 1 1
Jose Bautista RF 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0 0
Alex Gonzalez SS 6 0.167 0.167 0.667 1 1
Lyle Overbay 1B 18 0.059 0.111 0.118 0 0
John Buck C 12 0.250 0.250 0.833 2 4
Edwin Encarnacion 3B 3 0.333 0.333 0.333 0 0
Total 71 0.212 0.268 0.485 5 7
Yankees vs. Blue Jays
Season: 2010 Season: 2009 Season: 2008 All-Time
TIED: 0-0 NYY: 12-6 TIED: 9-9 NYY: 259-205
  • Before the game, Joe Girardi announced that Dave Eiland had taken an indefinite leave of absence to deal with a “personal issue”.  In his place, bullpen coach Mike Harkey will serve as the pitching coach.

« Newer Posts - Older Posts »